As someone who isn't big into social media at the moment, I didn't expect to find myself writing about TikTok. However, after witnessing the bizarre spectacle of the recent congressional hearing, I couldn't help but chime in on this issue since it's related to creativity as a whole. The situation surrounding TikTok has so many layers that this article practically wrote itself, so I'll break down what's really going on if you haven't been paying attention.
The widely-celebrated video-sharing app has taken the world by storm, amassing millions of global users. However, its swift ascent has been controversial as governments, corporations, and political interest groups attempt to ban or undermine the app. The U.S. government's recent efforts to ban TikTok sparked intense debate, with Facebook/Meta actively lobbying against the app. The TikTok dispute goes beyond data privacy and national security; it represents a struggle between those seeking to control information flow and those who champion creativity, expression, and openness.
The Comedy and Reality of a Congressional Hearing
The amusing and awkward moments of the congressional hearing featuring U.S. lawmakers and TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew will likely live on in memes and spoofs for years. One bewildering exchange involved a member of Congress asking, "Does the TikTok app access your home wifi?" The spectacle resembled an episode of the Chappelle Show or Family Guy but played out in reality. This raises the question: are these lawmakers disconnected from reality, or are they participants in a political game of misinformation and corporate lobbying? Upon closer examination, it becomes evident that the hearing was far from typical. They accused TikTok of privacy violations, an offense for which Facebook/Meta was previously found guilty and fined $5 billion.
Facebook/Meta's Lobbying Tactics
In a twist of irony, Facebook/Meta enlisted public relations firm Definers Public Affairs to disseminate damaging information about TikTok and persuade Congress to investigate the company. Definers Public Affairs established the "Freedom From Facebook" campaign to depict Facebook's competitors, including TikTok, as threats to user privacy and security. They also shared negative stories about TikTok with journalists and bloggers and coordinated a coalition of groups to demand a government inquiry into the company. The New York Times revealed that the "Freedom From Facebook" campaign aimed to divert attention from Facebook's scandals and frame its rivals as the true menace to user privacy and security. The Times also reported that the campaign was part of a larger effort by Facebook to conduct opposition research and lobby against competitors, including Google and Apple. Really Zuckerberg?
(That being said, it's essential to recognize any potential risks social media platforms pose, regardless of the platform.)
Facebook/Meta and the Cambridge Analytica Scandal
The Facebook/Cambridge Analytica scandal is an important reminder of the consequences of data privacy negligence. In this case, the personal information of millions of Facebook users was harvested without their consent and used for political advertising. The scandal exposed Facebook/Meta's failure to protect user data. It highlighted the hypocrisy of its campaign against TikTok, as it attempted to deflect attention from its shortcomings by targeting a competitor.
Data Privacy and Security: A Widespread Issue
It is important to note that accusations of government spying and data privacy violations are not exclusive to TikTok. Similar concerns about other social media platforms, including Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, have been raised. The real "threat" posed by TikTok is its capacity to circumvent traditional media gatekeepers and provide a platform for historically marginalized or silenced voices and perspectives. (Basically, some people in "charge" don't like how fast real information can spread unfiltered on Tiktok.)
The Struggle for Control over Information
The relationship between power and creativity has long been characterized by tension. Historically, traditional media outlets and cultural gatekeepers have determined what is deemed "worthy" of attention, often excluding marginalized voices and alternative perspectives. However, technological advancements and new platforms have disrupted these power structures, empowering individuals to create and share content and ideas globally.
The Democratization of Creativity and Its Consequences
This democratization of creativity has significantly impacted our cultural landscape, challenging the status quo and amplifying previously unheard voices. Yet, this shift has also encountered resistance from those groups intent on maintaining their influence and control. In TikTok's case, this opposition has manifested in government bans, corporate lobbying, and allegations of data privacy violations.
Potential Solutions and the Future of Social Media Platforms: Balancing Power and Oversight
The challenges faced by social media platforms, including TikTok, highlight the need for potential solutions or regulatory frameworks that may help address issues such as data privacy, content moderation, transparency, and international cooperation. While there are numerous ideas for improvement, these solutions might still be subject to the pendulum swings of power controlling the narrative of oversight, which could defeat the purpose of the implemented rules.
As we consider potential solutions like independent oversight boards, open-source social media platforms, public funding for alternative platforms, antitrust regulations, and community-based governance models, we must recognize that these measures might not entirely eliminate the influence of powerful entities. However, by striving to create more equitable and transparent systems, we can reduce the concentration of power and foster a more diverse and inclusive social media environment.
It's important to acknowledge that there may not be any perfect solutions, but by continuously exploring new ideas, engaging in dialogue, and promoting a culture of accountability and transparency, we can work towards creating a social media landscape that better serves the interests of all users. (Ex. - Who wants to put in work on social media for their brand, and they are unknowingly shadow banned by meta?) The resilience and adaptability of human creativity and innovation offer hope that, as we progress, we can develop more effective ways to balance power and oversight in the ever-evolving world of social media platforms.
The Role of Social Media in Empowering Creativity and Diverse Voices When Used Properly and Organically
Social media platforms, including TikTok, have the potential to significantly impact various communities by providing a space for a wide range of creators. When used correctly and organically, these platforms empower users to discuss social and political issues, share insights into multiple industries and topics, and foster a more inclusive and open cultural landscape without corporate oversight.
Social media platforms can break down barriers and democratize creativity by offering users the tools and freedom to express themselves. This environment allows diverse voices to flourish, bringing attention to unique perspectives that might not have been given the same exposure in traditional media.
However, it is crucial to recognize the importance of using these platforms organically, without the undue influence of corporations or other powerful entities that might attempt to control the narrative(Look what IG has turned into; it's just about pay-to-play). When used responsibly and authentically, social media can help bridge divides, amplify diverse viewpoints, and promote a more open and inclusive dialogue on a global scale.
A Warning from History: COINTELPRO and the Perils of State Surveillance
In this context, historical examples like COINTELPRO (an acronym for Counter Intelligence Program) in the U.S. are a stark reminder of the dangers of state surveillance and the suppression of dissent. COINTELPRO was a series of covert and often illegal FBI operations aimed at surveilling, infiltrating, discrediting, and disrupting domestic organizations between 1956 and 1971.
Various organizations targeted by COINTELPRO included civil rights groups, anti-Vietnam War activists, feminist organizations, and political movements. Tactics used in these operations ranged from spreading misinformation and sowing discord within organizations to orchestrating sabotage.
The democratization of creativity and the rise of social media have opened new avenues for people to challenge the status quo and speak their truth. Consequently, it is crucial to safeguard these spaces and ensure access for all, regardless of who wields power. COINTELPRO's dark history highlights the importance of vigilance, the protection of individual rights, and the need to prevent similar abuses of power in the future.
Final Thoughts
The TikTok controversy reflects the power struggles between governments, corporations, and interest groups, as well as the larger issue of censorship and control over creativity and expression. As the world continues to grapple with the implications of social media platforms on privacy, security, and creativity, it is essential to strike a balance that protects individual rights while fostering an environment where innovation and expression can thrive. By addressing the challenges faced by social media platforms and implementing potential solutions, we can work towards a future where creativity, transparency, and freedom of expression are safeguarded for all.
❤️🔥🌊🌙
